PMCC LEAP zero · CC eats the drop · CSP keeps falling after assignment
- Question 1
- Willing to own?
- Question 2
- Shares or LEAP?
- Question 3
- Cash for how many?
Same underlying, same IV: all four income structures can hand you a beautiful “annualized” number.
The difference is not the return. The difference is what you lose in the worst case.
A CSP loses the shares you are assigned; a CC loses a rally; a PMCC can lose the entire debit; the Wheel loses through “keep taking delivery as it falls, and the position gets heavier.” All four can make money. Only one has a worst case you can sleep through.
So the order of selection is not “which earns more,” it is “which worst case can I survive.” What follows is a process of elimination, not a recommendation table.
1. The conclusion first: rank by worst case, not by return
| Structure | Worst case | Nature of the loss |
|---|---|---|
| CSP (sell a put) | Assigned, then the stock keeps falling | Unbounded downside, theoretically to zero |
| CC (covered call) | Stock crashes; or rallies through the strike | Full downside + capped upside |
| PMCC (LEAP + short call) | The LEAP goes to zero | Up to 100% of the debit |
| Wheel (rotation) | Serial assignment | The more it falls, the heavier the position |
How far apart are the worst cases? In my own account: NAV $6,357.77, maintenance margin 49.4%, cash only 31% of NAV (TWS snapshot 2026-10-27). At this size, one assignment can consume the entire available margin — which is why CSP sits last in my order. Not because it does not make money, but because it is the fastest way to turn me from “the person collecting rent” into “the person forced to hold stock.”
2. Four questions, and the order cannot change
The questions are serial. An early veto means the later ones do not matter:
① If this underlying falls, am I willing to own it? No → CSP and Wheel are out entirely. Selling a put means “I am willing to buy at this price,” not “I think it will not fall.” The full argument is in Selling puts: the win rate is designed, the payout is not. I closed my last 200 RGTI shares in November and took share exposure to zero specifically to keep this line clean: assignment is an incident, not a plan (the PMCC assignment myth).
② Do I already hold shares or a LEAP? No → CC and PMCC are impossible. Covered means “you own the thing first.” A “covered” call without the asset is a naked call.
③ How many contracts does my cash actually cover? Not even one → that is not a CSP, it is a naked put. Your broker’s margin is not your money — it is someone else’s risk budget.
④ Can I spend ten minutes a week? No → do not run short legs that need rolling. Nobody watching the final days before expiry is the most common way sellers die.
Run all four and usually only one structure survives. That is the entire job of the matrix: it does not choose for you, it eliminates.
3. The four structures side by side
The capital commitment is completely different: a CSP is cash-secured (strike × 100), a CC is 100 shares you already own, a PMCC is the LEAP premium (roughly 30–50% of the shares), and the Wheel is staged (at its heaviest it equals a full stock position). The identity differs too: CSP is an insurer, CC is a landlord, PMCC is a leveraged landlord, Wheel is rotation.
All four “sell options.” Which one to use comes down to two columns:
| Structure | Use it when | Avoid it when |
|---|---|---|
| CSP | You want to buy lower and will take delivery | You do not want shares / cash covers less than one contract |
| CC | Long-term hold, want to lower cost basis | Strongly bullish / selling too much above cost |
| PMCC | Capital is short but you have a directional view | Short calls cannot cover the LEAP’s time decay |
| Wheel | Range-bound market, stable fundamentals | One-way decline / dense earnings calendar |
The PMCC row deserves a note: it is a solution to “not enough capital,” not a solution to “less risk.” LEAP leverage magnifies the worst case — my 35-lot NOK PMCC runs at 1.31x leverage with a 43% rent coverage ratio (full ledger). Leverage magnifies gains and losses on both sides, while short calls can only patch one side.
4. Four migration paths
A structure is not a lifetime choice; it follows the state of the position:
- CSP → (assigned) → CC → (called away) → back to CSP: the complete Wheel loop, and the only path that does not require a directional forecast (the full Wheel).
- Shares + short call: the everyday CC. Selling an in-the-money call is active trimming; selling an out-of-the-money call is collecting rent — two different jobs that get confused constantly (CC entry and exit design).
- LEAP + short call: the substitute when capital is short. But the number of short calls must not exceed the LEAP’s delta coverage, or a rally means “you lock yourself out of your own position” (the PMCC handbook).
- Use a spread instead of a naked sale when IV is high: cap the worst case with a long leg, at the cost of a capped return. When IV is high enough to make you uneasy, that trade is usually worth it (vertical spreads).
The only test for switching: after the switch, is the worst case smaller or larger? If you cannot say, do not switch.
5. What the matrix does not solve
- It does not pick a direction. It only answers “which structure.” Get the direction wrong and the right structure still loses — just more slowly.
- It does not answer “should I sell IV now?” That is another dimension: with the same delta and expiry, IV determines how much rent you collect (theta efficiency is a shadow of IV).
- It does not set position limits. How big one trade is, and how heavy one underlying is, belongs to the 2% rule, regardless of structure.
- Small accounts have a hard floor. An account with a bit over six thousand in NAV and 49.4% margin already used can run at most two structures at once; more is not diversification, it is a queue for a blow-up.
- If you are not willing to take delivery, you should not be a seller. That is not a strategy problem, it is an identity problem — selling options is running an insurance company, and paying claims is part of the business.
6. Five questions before entry
- What is the worst case in dollars? (Absolute, not a percentage.)
- What percent of NAV is that? Above 20% → do not open.
- Is there earnings before expiry? If yes, shorten the expiry or skip the trade.
- If assigned, do I have the cash? And what do I do next?
- If it moves +20% or −20% tomorrow, what exactly do I do?
If you cannot answer all five, you did not pick a strategy. You picked hope.
7. One line
A strategy is not chosen; it is what remains after elimination.
Eliminate the worst cases you cannot survive, then pick the highest-return structure among the survivors. Reverse the order and you are using return to advertise risk.
Data & Sources
- Updated 2026-11-12 | First published 2026-11-12
- Account data: TWS snapshot read directly (synced 2026-10-27 02:24 Singapore time), not manually entered
- NOK PMCC leverage and coverage: IBKR execution reports plus position snapshot; definitions in Premium Is Not Income
- Annualized figures are illustrative for structure comparison only and are not a return expectation
Risk Boundaries
This piece covers structure selection and worst-case ranking only. It is not investment advice and promises no return. All four structures can lose far more than expected in extreme conditions: gaps, short squeezes, earnings shocks, liquidity collapse. The matrix can eliminate trades that clearly should not be opened; it cannot absorb the one you get wrong.

